Skip to the content
CITY 05City Executive · Question 5 of 5

What is our next competitive advantage?

Great cities do not compete on everything. They dominate something — and the something has to be evidenced, not chosen from a list of aspirations.

What the question is actually asking

  • What can we become known for?
  • Technology? Manufacturing? Healthcare?
  • Logistics? Sports? Culture? Defense? Education?

The honest part

Why the obvious answer fails

Cities adopt advantage by announcement: a tech hub, a mobility corridor, a cultural capital. An advantage is not a positioning statement; it is a position other places cannot easily copy. If every comparable city can claim it in the same sentence, it is not an advantage — and the cost of a false one is a decade of diluted investment.

The mechanism

How Lawton answers it.

01

Test the candidate against five conditions

An existing capability that is hard to replicate, demonstrated employer demand, an asset specific to the place, defensibility over a decade, and evidence available now rather than promised for later.

02

Choose one, and state what you will stop

An advantage is a decision about focus. The record names the sectors the city will deprioritise, because a strategy without an exclusion has not chosen anything.

03

Give it a falsifying condition

The advantage case carries the evidence that would show it is not working — a demand measure, an employer commitment, a capital flow — so it is revised on evidence rather than defended on identity.

See it working

Six focus areas, held inside a command

Detroit's command carries six named focus areas, each with its own rationale and its own delivery link — advanced manufacturing, mobility, technology, logistics, the event economy and district development — and the office is measured on conversion, not on the list.

Open the Detroit command

What you receive

The Advantage Case

Set for three years, reviewed annually

  • The single claimed advantage, stated as a position
  • The five conditions and the standing of each
  • The sectors explicitly deprioritised, and what that frees
  • The falsifying condition and the date it is reviewed

What this answer does not establish

  • An advantage case is an argument from evidence, not a brand strategy. It can be wrong, and it says how you would know.
  • No advantage is claimed on an asset the record does not hold.

This is delivered as a standing office, not a study. The command can be yours this quarter.